258 Henrietta Street
CentralFort Erie, ONL2A 2K7Near Henrietta Cncession and Ellen St
- 13 beds
3 upcoming open houses
Drop in during an open house, or tour online — no appointment needed.
- Open houseDate TBDTime TBD
- Open houseDate TBDTime TBD
- Open houseDate TBDTime TBD
What this listing tells us
Attention Investors! Exceptional turnkey 5-Plex offering potential strong, stable rental income on a massive 82 ft x 233 ft lot in the growing community of Fort Erie. Welcome to 258 Henrietta Street - a rare opportunity to own a fully rentable multi-residential property with excellent cash-flow potential and future upside. This well-maintained investment property features 5 self-contained units across two separate buildings. The front building includes 2 spacious residential units, while the rear building offers 3 updated units, including three desirable 2-bedroom layouts. In total, the property boasts 13 bedrooms, making it an attractive option for investors seeking strong rental performance and long-term appreciation. Each unit is separately metered for hydro and gas, with tenants paying their own utilities - a major advantage for reducing operating expenses and maximizing net income. Recent improvements include updated shingles on both buildings, adding to the property's overall durability and ease of ownership. Ideally situated near schools, shopping, public transit, the Niagara River, the U.S. border, and a nearby college. The oversized lot also presents potential future development or value-add opportunities, subject to buyer due diligence and municipal approvals. A solid addition to any real estate portfolio with reliable income, strong tenant appeal, and long-term growth potential.
Cleaned for readability — original MLS® text was lightly de-abbreviated and decapitalized.
Listing, price, and tax history
Every previous listing of this property, every list-price change, and 5 years of estimated annual property tax — switch tabs to drill in.
| Date | Event | Status | Price | Change | MLS® | View |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 20, 2026 | ListedCurrent | For sale | $799,000 | — | X13151128 | This page |
| Mar 20, 2026 | Previously listed | Ter | $799,000 | — | X12905506 | View |
| Sep 11, 2025 | Previously listed | Ter | $849,000 | — | X12398555 | View |
| Jul 24, 2025 | Previously listed | Ter | $799,000 | — | X12313328 | View |
| Apr 14, 2025 | Previously listed | Ter | $950,000 | — | X12084995 | View |
Inside this property
Systems, finishes, room dimensions, and building information — pulled from the full MLS® feed.
Features & systems
Heating, cooling, parking, exterior, lot, possession, and more.
Systems
4- Heating
- Other
- Air conditioning
- None
- Water source
- Municipal
- Sewer
Getting around, schools & the block
Walkability and transit, the nearest schools, an interactive map of the exact spot, and what's nearby.
Points of interest classified by the MLS® feed.
- Other
The money — monthly cost, mortgage & return
Everything financial in one place: what you'd pay each month, a live mortgage calculator at the asking price, and what it could return as a rental.
Cost of ownership
A monthly snapshot at typical assumptions — personalize the mortgage just below.
How this home sits in the Fort Erie market
Live neighbourhood stats, the closed sales you'd negotiate against, and comparable active listings.
The Fort Erie market right now
Average sold price, days on market, and closed-transaction count for Fort Erie — sourced from MLS®.
- Avg sold price$602,017Last 30 days
- Median sold price$560,000Middle of the market
- Days on market56 dAvg from list to close
- Closed last 30d165MLS® transactions
We'll get you into 258 Henrietta Street — the seller pays our commission
On every MLS® listing in Canada, the seller's brokerage pays a cooperating commission to whoever brings the buyer. Buyer representation is free to you.
$0 to you. The seller pays our fee.
On every MLS® listing in Canada, the seller's brokerage advertises a cooperating commission for the buyer's agent. A Coldwell Banker Summit Realty agent represents you — you owe us nothing.
Property flags & disclosures
An automated scan of public records and news for anything a buyer should know about this specific address — liens, outstanding work orders, or stigma-related history. We never invent flags.
We scanned public records and news for liens, outstanding work orders, and stigma-related history (e.g. a former grow-op or fire) at 258 Henrietta Street and found nothing flagged. We re-check automatically as new records publish.
Common questions about this property
Tap a question to expand the answer. Short, direct answers tuned for AI search and voice assistants.
How much is 258 Henrietta Street listed for?
258 Henrietta Street is listed at $799,000 on the MLS® (listing X13151128). The price refreshes on Summitly within minutes of any MLS® change.
How many bedrooms, bathrooms, and square feet does 258 Henrietta Street have?
Coldwell Banker Summit Realty is a RECO-licensed Ontario real estate brokerage, independently owned and operated. Mortgage financing is arranged through Mortgage Squad Advisors. Summitly is the technology platform that powers this site. Listing data is sourced from MLS® and is provided for informational purposes only — not guaranteed accurate by the MLS® or its members. The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The Coldwell Banker® name and logo are trademarks of Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC.