Available on mobile

Take Summitly with you.

Browse listings, get instant alerts, and talk to your AI concierge — all from your pocket.

Download on theApp StoreGet it onGoogle Play

Weekly market briefing

The smartest move starts here.

Curated listings, price trends, and neighbourhood insights — delivered Sunday morning.

Summitly

Your trusted partner in real estate. We help you find your perfect home, make informed decisions, and connect with expert professionals across Canada.

Coldwell Banker Summit Realty

Explore

Map SearchAll Ontario CitiesBrowse ListingsBrowse RentalsSold HomesOpen Houses

Sell & Rent

Sell Your HomeHome ValuationList Your Rental — FreeRental PricingRenting on Summitly

Resources

CalculatorsGet Pre-QualifiedNews & InsightsGuidesCompareAI ConciergeFranchise

Company

AboutWhy SummitlyContactFind a RealtorCareers — Join SummitlyFAQs
310-3100 Steeles Ave W, Vaughan, ON, L4K 3R1
905-553-8500info@summitly.ca

©2026 Summitly. All rights reserved. Coldwell Banker Summit Realty, Brokerage — RECO Registration #6018570.

Privacy PolicyTerms of UseCookiesSitemap

Listing data is provided by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) via PropTx and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Coldwell Banker Summit Realty, Brokerage — an independently owned and operated Coldwell Banker franchise.

REALTOR® Disclosure▾

For listings in Canada, the trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Used under license.

    Summitly
    Buy
    Sell
    Rent
    Pre-con
    Meet ZaraMy HomeNews & Insights
    905-553-8500
    HomeBuySell
    For sale Listed 2 days ago

    350 McNicoll Street

    ·Tay, ON··

    • 2 beds
    Tay real estate›S13598820
    • Overview
    • History
    • Details
    • Location
    • Mortgage
    • Investment
    • Comparables
    • FAQ
    Open house & tour

    1 upcoming open house

    Drop in during an open house, or tour online — no appointment needed.

    • Open house
      Sun, Jul 26
      2026-07-26T14:30:00.000-00:00 – 2026-07-26T16:00:00.000-00:00
      Public
    Overview

    What this listing tells us

    Property description

    Welcome to 350 McNicoll Street! Whether you're stepping into homeownership or looking to simplify your lifestyle, you'll appreciate the extensive improvements that have already been completed throughout. Renovated from top to bottom, this beautifully updated 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom home is move in ready and offers an incredible opportunity for first time home buyers, downsizers, or investors looking for exceptional value. The bright, thoughtfully designed interior offers a functional layout that makes the most of every square foot, creating a warm and inviting space. Recent updates include a new foundation (2022/2023), roof (2024), plumbing (2024), drywall, Rockwool insulation, flooring, siding, patio sliding door, deck (2024), and all new appliances (2025), providing peace of mind so you can simply move in and enjoy. Situated on a generous lot, the property also features a large shed equipped with hydro, offering endless possibilities as a workshop, hobby space, or additional storage. Conveniently located close to local amenities you'll enjoy being just minutes from Patterson Park, the Port McNicoll Community Centre, scenic walking trails, beautiful Georgian Bay, and convenient access to Highway 12, making commuting and everyday travel a breeze. Offering the perfect balance of small town charm and everyday convenience, don't miss your chance to make 350 McNicoll Street your next home.

    Cleaned for readability — original MLS® text was lightly de-abbreviated and decapitalized.

    AI highlights by Zara
    History

    Listing, price, and tax history

    Every previous listing of this property, every list-price change, and 5 years of estimated annual property tax — switch tabs to drill in.

    DateEventStatusPriceChangeMLS®View
    Jul 23, 2026ListedCurrentFor sale$354,900 —S13598820This page
    Sourced from MLS® · includes all previous listings of this property · tap View to open the archived listing in a new tab
    Property details

    Inside this property

    Systems, finishes, room dimensions, and building information — pulled from the full MLS® feed.

    Features & systems

    Heating, cooling, parking, exterior, lot, possession, and more.

    • Systems

      4
      Heating
      Baseboard
      Air conditioning
      Window Unit(s)
      Water source
      Municipal
      Sewer
    Location & lifestyle

    Getting around, schools & the block

    Walkability and transit, the nearest schools, an interactive map of the exact spot, and what's nearby.

    📍 350 McNicoll Street
    Financials

    The money — monthly cost, mortgage & return

    Everything financial in one place: what you'd pay each month, a live mortgage calculator at the asking price, and what it could return as a rental.

    Cost of ownership

    A monthly snapshot at typical assumptions — personalize the mortgage just below.

    Est. monthly mortgage
    $1,744
    20% down · 25y · 5.50% — adjust below ↓
    Est. monthly property tax
    $102
    0.35% mill rate · ON
    The market

    How this home sits in the Tay market

    Live neighbourhood stats, the closed sales you'd negotiate against, and comparable active listings.

    The Tay market right now

    Average sold price, days on market, and closed-transaction count for Tay — sourced from MLS®.

    • Avg sold price
      $591,263
      Last 30 days
    • Median sold price
      $586,250
      Middle of the market
    • Days on market
      41 d
      Avg from list to close
    • Closed last 30d
      64
      MLS® transactions
    Full Tay market report
    Buy with Coldwell Banker Summit Realty

    We'll get you into 350 McNicoll Street — the seller pays our commission

    On every MLS® listing in Canada, the seller's brokerage pays a cooperating commission to whoever brings the buyer. Buyer representation is free to you.

    Free buyer representation · Coldwell Banker® affiliate

    $0 to you. The seller pays our fee.

    On every MLS® listing in Canada, the seller's brokerage advertises a cooperating commission for the buyer's agent. A Coldwell Banker Summit Realty agent represents you — you owe us nothing.

    Call now
    Due diligence

    Property flags & disclosures

    An automated scan of public records and news for anything a buyer should know about this specific address — liens, outstanding work orders, or stigma-related history. We never invent flags.

    Nothing concerning surfaced — all clear.

    We scanned public records and news for liens, outstanding work orders, and stigma-related history (e.g. a former grow-op or fire) at 350 McNicoll Street and found nothing flagged. We re-check automatically as new records publish.

    Frequently asked

    Common questions about this property

    Tap a question to expand the answer. Short, direct answers tuned for AI search and voice assistants.

    • How much is 350 McNicoll Street listed for?

      350 McNicoll Street is listed at $354,900 on the MLS® (listing S13598820). The price refreshes on Summitly within minutes of any MLS® change.

    • How many bedrooms, bathrooms, and square feet does 350 McNicoll Street have?

    Coldwell Banker Summit Realty is a RECO-licensed Ontario real estate brokerage, independently owned and operated. Mortgage financing is arranged through Mortgage Squad Advisors. Summitly is the technology platform that powers this site. Listing data is sourced from MLS® and is provided for informational purposes only — not guaranteed accurate by the MLS® or its members. The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The Coldwell Banker® name and logo are trademarks of Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC.

  1. 1 bath
  2. < 700 sqft
  3. Detached
  4. Built 51-99
  5. < .50 ac lot
  6. Asking
    $354,900
    $507 / sqft · MLS® S13598820
    Chat Zara
  7. Zara AI Estimate
    Live · refreshes nightly
    Estimated value
    $431,622
    $397,092Confidence range$466,152
    Asking vs estimate
    ↓below
    −$76,722
    (-17.8%)
    Asking is below estimate
    Run the affordability numbers

    Based on the city's average sold price, adjusted for 2 bedrooms (no sqft on file).

    Market analytics

    Homes like this in Tay sell in about 41 days — this one has been listed 2 days.

    Avg sold price
    $591,263
    Median sold
    $586,250
    Avg days on market
    41
    Recently sold
    64
    See comparable sales
    • Welcome to 350 McNicoll Street!
    • Renovated from top to bottom, this beautifully updated 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom home is move in ready and offers an incredible opportunity for first time home buyers, downsizers, or investors looking for exceptional value.
    • The bright, thoughtfully designed interior offers a functional layout that makes the most of every square foot, creating a warm and inviting space.
    • Situated on a generous lot, the property also features a large shed equipped with hydro, offering endless possibilities as a workshop, hobby space, or additional storage.
    Ask Zara a follow-up
    Sewer
  8. Parking & garage

    3
    Garage
    None
    Parking spaces
    2
    Driveway
    2
  9. Interior

    5
    Basement
    Crawl Space
    Family room
    N
    Kitchens
    1
    Total rooms
    5
    Laundry level
    Main Level
  10. Exterior & construction

    4
    Exterior
    Vinyl Siding
    Roof
    Asphalt Shingle
    Foundation
    Block
    Pool
    None
  11. Lot & land

    1
    Year built
    51-99
  12. Listing & possession

    3
    Occupancy
    Immediate
    Property style
    Bungalow
    Property class
    Detached
  13. Room-by-room · 6 rooms

    Every room with its dimensions, level, and notable features.

    Room dimensions

    Main level

    6 rooms
    • Bedroom 2
      Laminate
      7.6 × 8.0 ft
    • Bedroom
      laminate · w/o to patio
      9.5 × 7.9 ft
    • Kitchen
      laminate · window
      10.5 × 7.6 ft
    • Foyer
      Laminate
      10.7 × 4.2 ft
    • Bathroom
      laminate · 4 pc bath
      4.6 × 3.3 ft
    • Living Room
      laminate · large window
      11.0 × 10.6 ft
    Combined estimate
    $1,846
    Mortgage + tax · before condo / insurance

    Mortgage & affordability

    Today's best Canadian rates from Mortgage Squad, then a live calculator — adjust down payment, amortization, and rate, and email yourself the report.

    Today's rates · Powered by Mortgage Squad
    350+ lender access · Best rate matched in 2 min
    Lock my rate
    • Best
      5-yr Fixed · Insured
      4.09%
      0.40% below banks
    • 5-yr Fixed · Conventional
      4.34%
      APR · OAC
    • 3-yr Fixed · Conventional
      4.49%
      APR · OAC
    • 5-yr Variable · Variable
      4.85%
      APR · OAC
    Rates indicative · Updated today · OAC, subject to underwritingSee all Mortgage Squad rates →
    Affordability calculator
    Estimated monthly payment
    $1,744
    /mo
    based on the purchase price of $354,900
    $70,980 cash
    $283,920 financed
    $239,135 total interest
    Monthly payment$1,744/ month
    Principal54%$283,920
    Interest46%$239,135

    20% down · 25-yr amortization · 5.50% rate. Principal & interest only — taxes, condo fees, and insurance not included.

    Email this mortgage report to yourself

    Save the full affordability breakdown — down payment, monthly, interest paid, and today's Mortgage Squad rate — in your inbox. Create a free Summitly account to save it, get rate-drop alerts, and build a shortlist.

    Create account & email meor send as guest
    Get pre-approved in minutes

    Know exactly what you can afford — a no-obligation pre-approval from Mortgage Squad.

    Get pre-approved

    Rental income & return

    What this home could rent for and the return at the asking price — an AI estimate against real property tax and condo fees.

    Est. monthly rent
    low–high
    Gross yield
    rent × 12 ÷ price
    Cap rate (est.)
    net of tax + fees

    AI estimate for discussion only — not an appraisal or investment advice. Yield and cap rate are derived from the estimated rent versus the asking price and real property tax.

    Comparable detacheds that just sold in Tay

    Swipe the closed sales, then use the table for a side-by-side $/sqft comparison against this home.

    • 14808 HWY 12
      Sold
      Sign in for price
      14808 HWY 12
      Detached
    • 251 Mountain Avenue
      Sold
      Sign in for price
      251 Mountain Avenue
      Detached
    • 311 Armstrong Street
      Sold
      Sign in for price
      311 Armstrong Street
      Detached
    • 39 Becketts Side Road
      Sold
      Sign in for price
      39 Becketts Side Road
      Detached
    • 457 Hayes Street
      Sold
      Sign in for price
      457 Hayes Street
      Detached
    • 51 Hunter Avenue
      Sold
      Sign in for price
      51 Hunter Avenue
      Detached
    AddressBd / BaSqftSold$/sqft% of askSold
    350 McNicoll StreetThis home2 / 1700$354,900ask$507——
    14808 HWY 123 / 32,000—
    251 Mountain Avenue2 / 11,100—
    Sold prices are hidden under TRREB rules. Sign in to reveal them.

    More detacheds in Tay

    Active listings within ±20% of this asking price.

    • 9 EARLDOM Boulevard
      $399,900
      9 EARLDOM Boulevard
      Detached 3 1
    • 225 Park Street
      $409,900
      225 Park Street
      Detached 2 1
    • 23 Earldom Boulevard
      $349,000
      23 Earldom Boulevard
      Detached 2 1
    • 78 KING RD
      $309,999
      78 KING RD
      Detached 1 1
    • 120 Maple Street
      $399,999
      120 Maple Street
      Detached 4 2
    • 183 Paradise Avenue
      $379,000
      183 Paradise Avenue
      Detached 3 1
    AI-first listing data

    Zara's valuation, full price history, room insights, and live MLS® refresh — all in one feed. No more comparing 4 sites.

  14. One team, no handoffs

    Your realtor, mortgage broker, and offer-night closing team work side-by-side. One conversation, not three.

  15. Showings on YOUR schedule

    Same-day showings for shortlisted homes, evenings + weekends. Your Coldwell Banker Summit Realty agent coordinates with the listing brokerage.

  16. Mortgage that closes

    Pre-approval, rate hold, and 350+ lender access via Mortgage Squad Advisors — no juggling lender chats yourself.

  17. Public listing courtesy of RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd · displayed on Summitly per MLS® data-share rules

    350 McNicoll Street is a 2-bedroom, 1-bath, < 700 sqft. Full room dimensions and floor breakdown are in the 'Rooms' section of this page.

  18. When was 350 McNicoll Street built?

    350 McNicoll Street was built in 51-99. Construction style, foundation, roof material, and EnerGuide rating (when published) are in the 'Features' section above.

  19. What is the property tax for 350 McNicoll Street?

    The 'Property tax' tab in the History section shows the most recent annual tax for 350 McNicoll Street plus a 5-year breakdown with YoY % change. Monthly equivalent is shown alongside.

  20. How much would the monthly mortgage be on 350 McNicoll Street?

    The affordability calculator on this page shows an estimated monthly mortgage for $354,900 at 20% down, 25-year amortization, and 5.5% rate. Adjust the sliders to model your own down payment and rate.

  21. Has 350 McNicoll Street been sold before?

    The 'Listing history' tab above lists every previous MLS® listing of 350 McNicoll Street with its list date, sold price (when sold), and final status. Each row is colour-coded with price-change arrows.

  22. What neighbourhood is 350 McNicoll Street in?

    350 McNicoll Street is in Port McNicoll, Tay. The 'Neighbourhood' section below links to the live Tay real estate hub with average sold price, days on market, and current inventory.

  23. Is Tay a good place to live?

    Tay is one of ON's actively-tracked Summitly markets. The full Tay real estate hub covers live average sold price, days on market, and neighbourhood-level inventory.

  24. 311 Armstrong Street
    3 / 2
    1,100
    —
    39 Becketts Side Road4 / 2700—
    457 Hayes Street3 / 2700—
    51 Hunter Avenue3 / 31,100—